“Peer Review of Data Papers: Does It Achieve Expectations for Facilitating Data Sharing and Reuse?”

This paper presents a qualitative study of open peer review reports of data papers in a data journal Earth System Science Data. We examine to what extent the actual review practices of data papers align with identifying the most valuable datasets and promoting data reuse. We conclude that peer reviewers adopted a variety of criteria to evaluate data papers, but it is still challenging for reviewers to identify the most valuable datasets that should be reused. In addition, our findings demonstrate the correlation between data paper evaluations and subsequent reuse of the underlying datasets.

https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5130257

| Artificial Intelligence |
| Research Data Curation and Management Works |
| Digital Curation and Digital Preservation Works |
| Open Access Works |
| Digital Scholarship |